Back to Newsletters

YouTube Shorts Is Cutting Reach for Clip Channels

Issue #243 By

If clippers are a major part of how your stream grows, YouTube just made that a lot harder.

The short version:

  • What happened: YouTube is updating its Shorts recommendations to prioritize original content.
  • What it means: Channels that primarily re-upload other creators' highlights will likely see less distribution.
  • The takeaway: The "clipper model" (a strategy many big streamers have used to explode in popularity over the last year) is being significantly nerfed on the platform.

On October 1, YouTube updated its Shorts recommendations (opens in a new tab) to favor original content. Channels that mostly re-upload other creators' videos will be shown less often, and stream clip channels fit that description almost perfectly.

The scale of the clipping model

Clipping has turned into a massive, paid marketing machine for many streamers. N3on, for example, paid out over $1.4 million to 303 clippers (opens in a new tab) in just five weeks, and MrBeast has even launched his own dedicated clipping platform, Vyro.

For a lot of creators who have blown up in popularity recently, this "clipper model" has been a primary engine for discovery. It allows for rapid, high-volume growth by leveraging a network of creators to do the heavy lifting of promotion. However, YouTube is moving to make that specific growth loop much less effective.

What YouTube actually changed

Channels identified as primarily aggregating or re-uploading other creators' videos without significant changes will likely see less distribution within the Shorts feed. If you use clips from another creator, make sure you're adding real value through your own original commentary, unique edits, or storytelling. - TeamYouTube

YouTube is judging this on a channel-wide basis, not just a video-by-video level. It's also a ranking change rather than a direct monetization penalty, so there's no "strike" or email notification. There's no official start date either: the first real sign you've been flagged will likely be a drop in your views.

YouTube's Creator Liaison Rene Ritchie went into more detail on what doesn't count as "value" in a Creator Insider video (opens in a new tab):

Make sure you're adding real distinct value all your own. Not just VO descriptions of what's happening on screen, minor technical edits, or template-based bulk changes. [...] If your channel was previously aggregating or re-uploading and you shift towards original content, the recommendation system will re-evaluate reach. - Rene Ritchie, YouTube Creator Liaison

Does permission help?

YouTube hasn't clarified whether a clip channel you've actually authorized (or paid) is treated any differently. Its reused content monetization policy (opens in a new tab) is a separate rule, but it serves as a good guide for where YouTube draws the line, and it explicitly says the policy "applies even if you have permission from the original creator."

If you're posting clips from your own streams on your own channel, you shouldn't be affected. This update is clearly aimed at the "aggregator" space.

Twitch is going the opposite way

While YouTube is tightening the reins, Twitch is doing the opposite. In July, I wrote about how Twitch is turning clips into its discovery engine, rewarding viewers whose clips travel to TikTok and YouTube with Social Media Badges. Last month, CEO Dan Clancy also said Twitch is building a Recaps Feed (opens in a new tab) that stitches your clips into a highlight reel.

It's interesting to see this divergence. YouTube has been heading in this direction since it removed viewer clipping in April, and this new update takes the same approach to the Shorts feed.

Clip your own streams instead

The clips YouTube is happy to push are the ones you post yourself. I actually made a video on the OBS setup that records Shorts while you're live, ready to save with a single button press.

Each clip saves with its own audio tracks and a preset layout, so the visuals are ready to post the moment you're done. You can still tweak the mix in your editor, including muting the music if needed.

What This Actually Means for You

  • If you pay clippers per view: Start tracking views per clip channel over the next few weeks. Briefs that ask for specific commentary or context will likely hold up much better than straight re-uploads.
  • If you run a clip channel: You need to start adding something of your own to every Short. Reach will be re-evaluated, but YouTube hasn't said how long that "re-evaluation" takes.
  • If fan channels drive your discovery: Don't count on that traffic continuing. Your own Shorts are the only part of the ecosystem you actually control.

Results go in next week's issue.

Pete's Content Corner

My weekly picks from across the content creation world.

  1. Twitch is adding Chat Noise Reduction (opens in a new tab), an optional moderation setting currently labeled as a beta. You can set a minimum and maximum message length, cap the percentage of capital letters, block ASCII art and repeated messages, and limit chat to the languages or script you choose.
  2. Kick passed 1 million average viewers in a month for the first time in September, according to Streams Charts (opens in a new tab), up 21% on the record it set in August. Hours watched rose about 16% to 773.8 million.
  3. Patreon is retiring per-creation and first-of-the-month billing (opens in a new tab). If you're still on either, switch to subscription billing by October 31. Otherwise Patreon switches you automatically and pauses your billing until you log in and confirm the new prices.

Thanks, as always, for taking the time to read Stream Report.

Pete ✌️

Read next